I am utterly flabbergasted by the mostly raving praises by analysts with regard to the recently announced S$700Mil acquisition of the new Tai Seng data centre and business property at Science Park by Capitaland Ascendas REIT ("CLAR"). Yes, I have no doubt that the usual yield accretive argument and stable & resilient income streams from established tenants (Shopee) makes perfect sense. But the financing aspect of this acquisition exercise is a slap in the face of long term loyal retail Unit-holders with the severe dilution in their investment into CLAR via only a private placement instead of opening up to all unit-holders.
How bad is the dilution on long term unit-holders?
Most long term Unit-holders probably entered into CLAR at prices ranging from S$2.80 per unit to S$3.00 per unit. If one entered during the pre-COVID days, then it will be S$3.00 to S$3.50 per unit range. Worst still, CLAR management offered a 5% discount to the market price of S$2.6059 per unit on 27 May 2025, that is, S$2.47 per unit.
Overall, S$500Mil of private proceeds were raised to fund the purchase of the above mentioned properties at the discounted price per unit of S$2.470.
Parting thoughts
Personally, I thought that the CLAR management ought to have opened up the fund raising to all retail-unit holders instead of taking the easy way out and selling out long-term loyal unit-holders. Anyway, if queried, CLAR management will probably come up with the stupid excuses of (i) uncertainty of successful fund raising via preferential rights issue in current economic climate and/or (ii) the need for speed to close out the deal. This is extremely disappointing as this corporate action does not benefit existing retail unit-holders and is a stab in their back.
Felt Abit cheated too as another unit holder
ReplyDeleteThink can only protest a bit at AGM on the high-handed way this exercise was done.
DeleteGonna played out in text book fashion.
ReplyDeleteRetail investors are minority.....so lack the influence and power....guess have to suck thumb at the disappointing fund raising conduct.
Delete