Tuesday, 14 December 2021

Dasin Retail Trust On The Verge Of Bankruptcy Declaration? Will It Be Suspended From Trading on SGX?

This is a follow up on my previous post on Dasin Retail Trust ("Dasin") on 18th September 2021 with regard to its debt crisis of S$500Mil since the syndicated bankers were willing to only grant a short term extension of 5 months from July 2021. The day of reckoning for Dasin approaches this week with the bank loan officially being in default on 19th December 2021 if it is unable to secure support from the syndicated bankers. Up till today, there is still no news being released by Dasin's new Trust Manager, Sino Ocean on SGX. Dasin's senior management has been silent since the last announcement made to the public on 7th November 2021 on the change in new Trust Manager. Unit prices for Dasin also dropped sharply and is now near its all time low at S$0.375 per unit in stark contrast to S$0.785 per unit during its peak this year. The silence for so many weeks in the face of imminent loan default is deafening. Are we witnessing the calm before the storm?
1. Taking calculated risk
I am still holding on to my small stake in Dasin Retail Trust as my investment thesis is that since the new Trust Manager, Sino Ocean which took over is a listed company on the Hong Kong Stock Exchange and well-known, the bankers will be willing to grant a long term extension of the due bank loan instead of rolling into a default and proceeding with creditor winding up process. Forced sales of investment properties is not going to be good for all stakeholders. Its current dividend yield is close to +14.2% based on its last unit price of S$0.375 per unit as at 14 December 2021.
2. Liquidation stress testing of realisable assets to repay bank loans and Unitholders
I have written in to the Customer Relation Officer on their website but till now have not received any reply on the status of its bank loan negotiation. In the worst case scenario, we have to assume that the fair value of the investment properties in Dasin's books have been severely inflated. If distressed selling price is at a discount of <-47.3%> of its last disclosed numbers, then this will mean a total loss for current investors-pls see below screenshot for illustrative simulation model. Not impossible given the case of Eagle Hospitality Trust. Also, given that China property debt crisis from Evergrande- if not managed well- may lead to a case of economic meltdown in the entire China market across all sectors. However, I am keeping my fingers crossed that the discounted selling price is at most only 40% off the last valuation in order to recoup back some of the investment costs. 
Parting thoughts
I have no idea how my tiny foray into Dasin will turn out. My investment thesis may turn out to be totally wrong. If so, this will be the 2nd SGX listed Trust (within this 2 years) that collapsed with investors losing all of their investments. The only good thing about Dasin is that the results will be known quickly by next Monday (20th Dec 2021) latest. It will either increase by maybe 50% from good news on renewal of bank loan or be suspended indefinitely due to default of bank loan when the announcement is released.


Please also see my previous posts on Dasin:

10 comments:

  1. Contacted their IR department and the reply was "The refinancing of the offshore and onshore facilities is still in the documentation stage".

    The email contact: ir@dasintrust.com

    ReplyDelete
  2. https://www.ifre.com/story/3182199/dasin-retail-trust-raises-s435m-club-dzhrh9rzsz

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. wow, do you have a screenshot of the article ? I don't have membership for it

      Delete
    2. Sorry I don’t! It is very strange indeed since no official news so very confused.

      Delete
  3. https://www.ifre.com/story/3182199/dasin-retail-trust-raises-s435m-club-dzhrh9rzsz same no membership. But hopefully true and bounce back

    ReplyDelete
  4. Trading halt since this morning 20 Dec 2021. The lack of prompt response by Dasin Retail Management seems to suggest very bad news. They seems to have been caught off-guard. Also, the last round of delay in paying distribution to unit-holders does not feel right if read together. Hope that the trading halt does not become a permanent suspension.

    A few possibilities I reckon:

    1.Could also be they managed to only get part of the syndicated loan re-financed and need an immediate rights issue like First REIT to repay portion that cannot renew;

    2. Worst is uncovering of accounting improprieties by the new Trust Manager which took over on top of the loan not being renewed. All financial modelling stress test on the valuation will fall off the cliff and Dasin maybe close to worthless after auctioning off properties to repay outstanding bank loans even in good market conditions.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Announcement is out. Renewal for loans still unable to be concluded. However, Dasin averted the loan default crisis for now. The syndicated bankers gave another 3 months of extension from 20 December 2021 till 19 March 2022. Something not smelling right here. SGX better start sending their queries to Dasin Senior Management.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. sent some questions to IR too.. regarding the new request from minority lenders.. Hopefully they reply

      Delete
    2. reply from IR was the emphasis of the word "Minority lender" form the report.

      Delete
  6. Still the damage in credibility is done for now. Will keep trading well below NAV I guess. Let’s see…

    ReplyDelete