SREITS Crashed Again- REITS Or SG Banks More Attractive?

SREIT tumbled down again over the past 2 weeks. Interestingly, I see a number of folks like Josh Tan buying into Mapletree Industrial Trust (“MIT”) or Master Leong strong preference for Mapletree PanAsia Commercial Trust (“MPACT”) to take advantage of the recent “crash” while others like the famous AK71 preferred the local trio of DBS, OCBC and UOB banking stocks as better buy than REITs. For the latter, the local banks are only paying out 50%-60% of their earnings as dividends to shareholders while ploughing back 40%-50% of their earnings into the business which should theoretically keep building up their Net Assets Value and eventually their market price should gradually increase. So it gets kinda of confusing on whether one should buy more REITs during the current downturn for the REITS sector or accumulate more local SG bank stocks given the different opinions of their preferences. 

1. Time to Chiong/Accumulate more SREITs while prices crash and interest rate being slashed gradually into 2025?

Personally, I have mentioned before my thoughts in September 2024 that most of our SREITs are now priced fairly given that we should not expect future interest rate to be near the previous decade of zero interest rate environment. Distribution yield of 5.5% to 6.0% for blue-chips SREITs should be the norm now. Anything that is lower will not compensate for the additional risk premium one undertakes relative to the local risk-free rate. 

MIT’s distribution yield of 5.96% at unit price of  S$2.27 per unit is decent. But I would not say super attractive given that its market value per unit is at a huge premium over its NTA per unit. Since MIT is my second largest holdings already, I did not add on any further.

As for MPACT, while its distribution yield is now at an attractive 6.9% (@ S$1.23 per unit) and its market value per unit is at a large discount over its NTA per unit, the stock market maybe pricing in substantial worsening in distributions from its Hong Kong, China and Japan exposure. Also, its crown jewel of Mapletree Business City seems to be losing its luster. So I guess the usual high risk high reward adage will apply here. It thus depends on which crystal ball you are gleaning into for whether the foray here will reap handsome return or just a lackluster one.

2. Local Banks With Splendid Results Expected Into 2025.

There is no doubt that DBS, UOB and OCBC trio have been having a good run since last year due to the sudden spike in interest rate on their net interest margin and also wealth management business. But if recession comes, bank stocks will also crash and risk of bad debts increase exponentially. I will be staying away from banks for now unless there is a substantial correction in their prices. 

Parting Thoughts and My Watchlist.

Given the recent developments as aforesaid mentioned, I have been focusing my monthly nibble size investments into Endowus bond funds and Keppel Ltd. I thought that overseas REIT such as Link REIT looks more attractive given its market price is almost 40% off its net book value per unit and giving a distribution yield of 7.6% with 21% leverage ratio.